Topic: Does everyone really create their own reality?

This arrived in my inbox this morning and I think it's an article worth sharing....

DOES EVERYONE REALLY CREATE THEIR OWN REALITY?

Over the years it has been an honor for me to advance and defend new age and holistic spirituality. I love its open-mindedness, its embrace of metaphysics and the way it combines spiritual work with healthcare. But I have also despaired at times about its apparent lack of morality and compassion when faced with the realities of people's suffering.

This coldness is often explained away with half-baked ideas about how energies, karma and the laws of attraction work. This often reach a peak of disturbing smugness when a new age 'philosopher' faced with cruel suffering says authoritatively: 'People create their own reality' or  'Their soul chose it - its their karma' or 'Everything is perfect in God's Plan - you just need to perceive it differently'. People who say such things seem to have no idea how smug and nasty they sound. Nor of the hurt they cause.
 
Fourteen years ago I had a lower back crisis in which three disks herniated and a tendon tore. The pain was as high on the scale as it can go. I was bed-ridden, then on sticks and it took seven years to recover. Early on, as I hobbled awkwardly on sticks, a new age woman came up to me, poked her face in mine and loudly stated, 'You know what Louise Hay says about lower back crises, don't you!' She was typical of many.

A friend recently had a severe heart crisis, was suddenly taken to hospital and told that his life was at risk.  He told me that what really frightened him was the thought of informing his spiritual friends, because they would use it as an opportunity to be self-righteous and tell him what he was getting wrong in his life.

Of course in both my and his case there were good lessons to be learned, but our life or mobility were threatened and we deserved compassionate friendliness. Isn't spiritual development about increasing compassion and love? It does not help to have someone chiming, 'You asked for it. Told you so.' Even if we did create those illnesses, kindness and support are needed so that we can begin to understand the process..

These minor examples of personal distress are nothing compared to the more dramatic tragedies being endured on the world stage. What follows is recent testimony from a woman at the centre of the Darfur crisis (New Internationalist, June 2007):

'My baby boy was thrown on the fire in front of me. My daughter was older. They thought she was a boy so they slaughtered her too - they snapped her neck like a chicken. Some of the children they threw down a well …. After they raped the women they cut off their breasts to make them suffer. They used those of us who were left as donkeys.'

Her experience is not unique. Recently too there has been the incident of the little girl kidnapped in Portugal, the tip of an iceberg of the sexual abuse faced by hundreds of thousands of children every day, not to mention the thirty thousand children who daily die of starvation.

"In spite of everything, I still believe that people are really good at heart." Anne Frank.

Surely all this suffering can only be approached with stillness, humility and wisdom of the heart. Not with half-baked metaphysics and denial. It is pure ignorance, shameful and cold-hearted emotional cruelty to suggest that these women and children asked for this destiny, deserved it, chose it or created their own reality.  It completely misunderstands karma and the laws of attraction.

There is a frequent error of assuming that souls have complete control and choice over their incarnations. New souls entering for the first time, for example, may simply be drawn to where there is a newly conceived fetus. They may have no choice but to participate in the collective rhythm and cycle. There are more dynamics in incarnation than simple choice.

Equally we do not create our lives in isolation. We pass through collective historical and karmic events over which we may have little individual power. We are participants as souls and as biological creatures in a constellation of relationships that includes our species, our gender, our family, our ancestors, our ethnicity and faith. Our parents and children, for example, are within us, as we are also within them.  We are not just individual souls creating our own individual lives and futures. We are also subjects of the group soul and our histories and futures are entwined. As a species we have created a shared karma of suffering, and it is as a collective that we experience, redeem and heal it. The collective affects even the most forceful individual.

The redemption of all this lies in the fact that each of us has the freedom and power to adopt our own inner attitude regardless of circumstances.  I am inspired, for example, by the Catholic priests who chose the way of self-sacrifice and walked with their Jewish parishioners into the Nazi gas chambers.

"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." Edmund Burke

It is also completely banal and naïve to suggest that everything in God's world is good and that it is all a matter of perception.  Faced with the reality of a three-year old child being sexually abused, it is simply not possible to make such a statement and be moral. It is in facing reality, not denying it, being in our hearts, that we grow and become wiser.

At the same time I fully appreciate how difficult it is to be fully present to suffering. For some people it is overwhelming because it triggers their own pain. But sooner or later on the spiritual path we have to develop the courage and strength to stay stable and loving when faced with these horrors.  In the words of Carl Jung: One does not become enlightened by imagining figures of light, but by making the darkness conscious.

All my love

William

www.williambloom.com

Join me in Peru to celebrate December 21st 2012 - Visit: http://2012awakeningretreat.com/

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

Ayahuasca wrote:

I think it's an article worth sharing....

you were right smile

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

Ayahuasca wrote:

This arrived in my inbox this morning and I think it's an article worth sharing....

"In spite of everything, I still believe that people are really good at heart." Anne Frank.

Realy love this quote.....  no farther from the truth she could have been

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

Good article.  Thanks for posting it, Ayahuasca.  I realize that Mr. Bloom is approaching this subject in the context of his own involvement in the New Age movement.  I would suggest, though, that all the traits he mentions are not just descriptors of that particular group of people, but are more universal to all of us.  Both the positive ones, like open-mindedness, a love for metaphysical explorations, and a marriage of healthcare with a spiritual approach to life and the negative ones like callousness toward the suffering of others and a spiritual arrogance that can lead to a lack of morality can be readily seen in just about every group of religious and spiritual seekers I can think of.  If he is trying to get people to take a good look in a mirror, he might want to consider directing his message to a much wider audience.
When all is said and done, I have to agree with Anne Frank

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

I think we create our reality to the extent that a positive vibration (the result of right thinking, a positive outlook and perhaps spiritual practice) is more likely to attract positive things/experiences to it, while the opposite is true for a negative vibration. All energy you send out is returned to you, that's karma. smile However, some people do suffer terrible tragedies with no apparent cause whatsoever, and for those who are brainwashed with new-age concepts to essentially say "they brought it on themselves" is incredibly callous.

I do believe that certain events are predestined, and sometimes things that seem awful/unbearable when they happen turn out to be the greatest learning experiences later. (That's certainly been true for me.) There is also karma created in past lives to take into consideration. In conclusion, I think that if you view everything that happens in life as an opportunity for growth, then you can transmute even the negative events into something positive.

"Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to pause and reflect." - Mark Twain

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

Great article, much needed. I agree with Anne Frank though.. I think it's a matter of conspiracy.. not precisely humanity's fault.. like if you say some people have no hope because they're "evil".. isn't it like saying they have no hope because they "chose" their horrendous life circumstances?... besides, as far as "blame" goes... forgiveness is *free*, if you can just manage to forgive yourself.. if you say evil is ignorant, well evil says you are ignorant.. it is always ignorance that is to *blame*, because being ignorant takes a high toll on a person...

nothing is sacred, the deconstructing and letting-be of all things, clarity of sight, the realization of no-thing(s), Nothing

7 (edited by lala 2007-06-27 14:18:11)

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

I think that the new age lack of compassion, which has been documented by many other people, is a combination of the toxic narcissism that is so ingrained in Americans and the result of people bringing their fundamentalism into so-called new age or alternative thought and culture.  The idea of crime and punishement, retribution and redemption is part of all fundamentalist ethos, including Christianity, but certainly not limited to it. People have taken their fundamentalism and just transferred it over to the new age, is all.
I think it also has to do with the argument about whether or not people have individual souls that continue into the next world(s). It seems to be the people in the new thought religions who go with the idea that we are all just a blob of consciousness separated into different forms and bodies that are the most cut off from empathy. Kind of a: just live out your life an accept your fate or karma and go back into the pool for another round of learning experiences. This negates the importance of individual soul evolution and what happens to a person as a result of taking on incarnation. I think it matters what happens to individual souls here, even if there is some ego involvement with a less-awake soul.
After many years of personal research and experience, I have to say that I think that there is definitely something interfereing with human soul evolution and for us all working and living together in harmony. This interference cannot merely be explained by ignorance. Indeed, there seems to be a very driving intelligence  behind the cruelty and lack of love that we perpetrate on each other.
The new age can be an opportunity for people to work energetically on clearing and releasing their soul entrapments, or it can be just another trip for people to bring all of their lack of consciousness and denial about what really goes on with energy on this planet. That seems to be the real choosing on one's own reality.-lala

don't judge a book by its name

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

Ayahuasca wrote:

This coldness is often explained away with half-baked ideas about how energies, karma and the laws of attraction work. This often reach a peak of disturbing smugness when a new age 'philosopher' faced with cruel suffering says authoritatively: 'People create their own reality' or  'Their soul chose it - its their karma' or 'Everything is perfect in God's Plan - you just need to perceive it differently'. People who say such things seem to have no idea how smug and nasty they sound. Nor of the hurt they cause.

Thanks for posting this.  I've come across this same complaint many times, and after pondering it a while, I have concluded that is is not a valid argument against reality creation.


"Smug and nasty" are subjective.  That the truth of the matter is not what one WANTS to hear does not invalidate the truth itself.


And as for "compassion"  I think Don Juan got it right... that compassion is an attempt the make the other person like yourself, thus it arises from selfishness.  If I could take away a person's pain, I would only be denying the "sufferer" the lesson to be found therein and insure that they encounter the same lesson again down the road.  And that would not be the proper thing to do, imo.


Now certainly, when another presents their pain, one may choose to be kind and supportive, and there's no error in that, I believe.  But one must walk a fine line.  For example, perhaps the sufferer is in the grip of some sort of self-delusion, and a word from another might allow truth to replace the illusion.  In that case, is it kinder to offer truth, which they might perceive as painful, or keep quiet, offer consolation only, thus permitting their suffering to continue?  Is it not possible what withholding truth actually causes more "hurt" than offering it does?  But the fact is that if one chooses the latter option, they will still think that you are a "nice" person.  So then, if that is one's motivation, then the keeping quiet was for selfish reasons, see?


Sickness and suffering would not exist if they did not have a purpose to fulfill.  That is the truth, in my opinion of course.  hmm  Otherwise, it is all random in origin.


And one last thing, blaming the sufferer for their sickness is a human trait, not a new age movement one.  For example, when smokers get ill, it is not uncommon for others to hold them responsible for their illness.  So, in that sense, this whole argument is sort a strawman one from the get go.

Some say the world will end in fire,
Some say in ice.
From what I've tasted of desire
I hold with those who favor fire.
But if it had to perish twice,
I think I know enough of hate
To say that for destruction ice
Is also great and would suffice.  ~Robert Frost

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

A tricky one, on one hand the article is Anthropomorphizing things a little and on the other  we have the blame the victim mentality.

Its not like we are fractions of the whole but rather versions of the whole.

10

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

Good food for thought indeed.

"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." Edmund Burke

Yup, complacency.

Which makes the statement, "You brought it on yourself"  seem full of apathy or heartlessness.

Althought, it may not be a wise statement to make, I sure most of us, feel for the suffereing of others.

During a down time recently , when I felt low , I thought the following to myself, ...
"Agh, why am I bothering, just forget everything you've learnt, felt or experienced and move on with your life as before, stop trying to "better" yourself, you don't need all this worry."
"Why should I bother when people don't take frindge-knowledge seriously, all those I speak to don't understand or think I'm mental."
"Responsibility."
"You and those like you have a responsibility to mankind".
"To forget all knowledge now and make no attempt to improve your world or the world around you would be criminal".


Althought we are not directly responsible for the worlds ills and horrors, we should feel an indirect responsibility, a responsibility not only to help heal but to help heal permanently.

Saying anyone has brought anything on themselves , may be true in some cases but saying you were killed by an axe to the head, or died in a horrific car-crash with your spouse because you asked for it, seems a little unreasonable.

Remember others motto: Out of chaos, order.

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

I don't believe that anything happens to us without our prior consent.  Whether it's correct or not to consider that giving of consent as "asking for it" would be a moot point to argue.


Unless you believe that axe murders and fatal car crashes are completely random occurances.... which I do not believe. 


Healing cannot occur in an environment of deceit, imo.

Some say the world will end in fire,
Some say in ice.
From what I've tasted of desire
I hold with those who favor fire.
But if it had to perish twice,
I think I know enough of hate
To say that for destruction ice
Is also great and would suffice.  ~Robert Frost

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

If karma comes from violating freewill, then that shows freewill violations exist. Therefore there are people whose freewill is being violated in an undeserved manner. That it is undeserved is what brings on the karma, since freewill violation creates an imbalance that initiates a counter-balance. So I don't think everyone who suffers necessarily brought it upon themselves. If everyone did get what they deserved, then  you could harm anyone you wanted and not feel guilty because you are just helping them pay back their karma. That doesn't make sense, therefore freewill violations and undue suffering exist in certain cases.

And even those who have brought it upon themselves still deserve support and compassion if that functions remedially in a spiritual way. The thing about resolving karma is that it involves grasping and applying a core lesson that was ignored when the freewill violation was committed (committed upon oneself, or upon another) so if you keep helping someone who keeps abusing your help to further evade learning that lesson, then that is no help at all. But I think there should be enough compassion to answer a call for help if the call is sincere.

Also, if you think about what happens to humans versus animals versus trees versus rocks, you'll see there is a gradation there in terms of how much of what happens is part of 'destiny' and 'lessons' and 'karma'. When a rock is crushed to make gravel, it is at the mercy of the rock crusher who has more power, but nothing much is being violated there because a rock is very basic.  So what I'm saying is that people who are young or embryonic souls, who are not all that conscious, fall more in line with the laws of accident, chance, probability, law of the jungle, natural selection, etc... than those who have more. The less consciousness, spiritual clout, and freewill something has, the less 'destiny' and 'lessons' and 'karma', the more you will see it be at the mercy of natural forces and more powerful beings. That's another reason I don't think everyone deserves what they get as a function of karma, because not everyone is even at the level of operating solely within metaphysical causes and effects. Some are partially or completely at the level of operating within physical causes and effects, and that's where accidents and overpowering takes place.

Compassion is best applied where it can find useful application. That limits it to your personal sphere of influence, and even then only to those who regardless of their errors truly want it and can actually benefit in a positive way from it. Discernment, discretion, and wisdom balance out compassion, and it's okay to use tough love or silence when nothing else would work. Since it is difficult or impossible to know at a glance where everyone in the world stands in regard to the true causes of their suffering, I find it necessary to strike a balance between having just enough compassion to answer a sincere call for help, and not wasting my energy being constantly anguished to the point of debilitation by the suffering of those in the world who are way beyond my sphere of influence.

Acquiring fringe knowledge is like digging for diamonds in a mine field.

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

Aquarius wrote:

I don't believe that anything happens to us without our prior consent.

But what does "OUR" mean?  I can think of several things that happened to me that my mind didn't consent to.  For instance, in the fall of '04 I was making a left turn and an SUV blew a green light, hit me, and could've killed me if I hadn't sped up so that she would only smash the back half of my car and give me whiplash.  I quite clearly recall the SUV coming at me, not wanting it to come at me, trying to avoid it.  I didn't mentally consent to it.  My thoughts were more on the order of: "Oh shit...no...bad...this is gonna hurt...get yourself out of the way!"

Am I open to the possibility that a higher part of me mocked-up the car crash, though?  Absolutely.  I did learn from it.  My body and mind weren't in on it, however; they only found it funny later on. 

The same point can be made about the Sudanese women who were gang-raped recently.  I bet if you talked to them, the majority would not tell you that as it was happening they were thinking: "Oh, at last!  Please, please, tear open my vagina and anus!  Mutilate my chest and burn my children--you won't get a fight from me."  ...I doubt it went down like that. 

I'm also asking myself the question: what is so terrifying about the idea that things happen to us randomly and without our control?  I can't come up with an answer.  I don't find it particularly scary.  I mean, I don't want to have complete control taken away from me--like those Sudanese women--but I feel like even if it did happen I could survive it.

You can't change a tiger's stripes,
but you can avoid its teeth.

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

I just want to say that karma is a can of worms I would rather not open here.


I was thinking in terms of one's higher self ALLOWING an experience.  Speaking of "asking for" an experience or "bringing it upon yourself" are spins of that.


Yes, clearly there are young souls who fall under the law of accident, but those same souls are unlikely to be complaining about the lack of compassion shown by new agers.  Obviously such people lack free will, so there's not much of a real violation of free will in that case.


And don't get me wrong, I don't think that to say "you brought it on yourself, you know" is a appropriate thing to say... rather, my point is simply that particular complaint about non-biblical  or new-age spiritual thought is not a valid argument against the idea that one creates their own reality.


Tom, I think I have seen you say that what a person experiences at any given moment is perfect for that person in terms of their location on their path and lessons that are needed.  I think our higher selves DO bring us what on the surface might seem negative things for the lessons contained therein.

Some say the world will end in fire,
Some say in ice.
From what I've tasted of desire
I hold with those who favor fire.
But if it had to perish twice,
I think I know enough of hate
To say that for destruction ice
Is also great and would suffice.  ~Robert Frost

Re: Does everyone really create their own reality?

Aquarius wrote:

...what a person experiences at any given moment is perfect for that person in terms of their location on their path and lessons that are needed.  I think our higher selves DO bring us what on the surface might seem negative things for the lessons contained therein.

I'm not Tom, but I would like to say that I think that that's a point-of-view that's well worth adopting because it makes easier to go on.  I have no idea if it's true or not.

You can't change a tiger's stripes,
but you can avoid its teeth.