Warning, probable gross generalisations ahead.
In my experience, living way out in the bush here in Australia, I have found the older people here (60+) to be much more resilient, down-to-earth and yes, real. They have a general mistrust of authority and in particular bureaucracy, although most are natural 'conservative' voters so there are some fundamental disconnects when one probes deeper. For example, they'll trust the government 'to do the right thing' on the fear based issues of which they have (or wish to have) little understanding: terrorism, border control etc., yet distrust them intensely on the issues that impact their own lives (eg. all the pointless rules and regulations that go with farming in particular, visiting doctors and other 'professionals').
The third party in Australian politics has always been linked to the refrain that they're there "to keep the bastards honest" so it is true to say many country Australians, at least, have a total mistrust of the government, whomever is in power. We get fined if we don't vote so you can see the contempt for which (or is it apathy) most Australians have for the political process.
With regard to automatic responses, I do not see such in this age group. They are considered and sometimes strident in their responses and views. They want to hear how you are, not just uttering a few words for the sake of it. Many are/were farmers whose livelihood and indeed lives sometimes have dependend upon their ability to think for themselves and be relatively independent of the rest of the world. When they retire, most are still very active and involved in the community, and on the whole, very caring and in remarkably good health - better health certainly than I see in many of their 40 - 60 year old 'children' and sadly then their children.
It has interested for a long while why this might be so, and I appreciate I might only be interacting with the healthy septugenarians +, yet go down a generation and the chronic health issues are much worse, issues that have the ability to kill people off before they get to sixty, let alone a robust eighty-five.
I have come to believe it is a mix of the nutrient-dense food and self-responsiblity that was instilled into this earlier generation at an earlier age. They might not have had all the food they wanted, nor even the affection, but many had high-quality, nutrient dense food and this, and their generally resilient upbringing, with a lot of self-responsibility instilled into it, appears to have served them well. Their lives also had meaning from dawn to dusk, and even those that have retired remain vibrant parts of the community. In fact, sometimes I am astonished at their energy.
Having lived on the coast for several years, with a lot of retirees, previous to this, the comparison could not have been more stark. Many there were somewhere between say obesity and death, with mowing the lawn to within an inch of its life on a regular basis, having the house spotless, or watching the neighbours, their only distractions from eating, sleeping and drinking. Programmed responses were the norm, supermarket food trolleys were laden with crap to eat and there seemed to be no meaning with which to live from one day to another, merely existence.
Of course, there are country people like this and town people who show resilience and yes, life! but these were the impressions overall that I gained. The coast life provided ample opportunity for easy walking, paddling and enjoyment of the free joys - sea air, fantastic views, sunshine, wildlife but compared to 'going down the club' or sitting at home in front of the telly, or shopping, nature did not seem to rate highly. The more meaning was lost, for this was all I could put it down to in the end, the more 'programmed' and 'automatic' people seemed to become. Not to mention firmly xenophobic.
I talk about the protective effects of nutrient-dense food because I have experience of the effects of nutrient imbalance, minerals specifically, on people's health; mental, physical and emotional. It's not the whole enchilada, it can't be, but it does bring up some interesting (well, to me anyway) points. We are all aware of the 'attention deficit child' but the opposite is very apparent in the older age groups where often clogged bowel - due to poor digestion and food choices, equals clogged brain. If the brain doesn't have the nutrients it needs, as with the rest of the body, the light begins to go out. Far be it from me to suggest that we are merely biochemical beings, of course not, I am purely talking 'physical' effects here of nutrient-deprived food since most humans still need to eat.
In this state, one doesn't then have to be abducted or replaced to become a shell of one's former self. The eyes are dull and the lights are out, all by one's own hand. And it is an insidious pit to climb out of because the amotivation caused by chemical imbalance makes choosing life-affirming foods (presuming they are grown in nutrient-dense soils which is so rarely the case) even harder because, frankly, one can't think straight, even if one has the understanding to do so. Couple that with a heavy dependence on social alcohol and there go a few million more brain cells a week.
So this I see a lot in the elderly who live without meaning, but not so much in those who have meaning which appears to drive them to care more what they're eating, drinking, how they're living (the quality or lack thereof). Does the lack of meaning lead to poor choices, or does the poor sustenance lead to lack of meaning?
Certainly the older country folk have their own veggie gardens, this is not so prevalent in their sons and daughters. And whilst they might have and still use chemicals on their farm (some of which are mandated by law), they don't on their veggies. As I said, disconnects abound.
The 40 - 60s age group are also very interesting. They didn't have the 'nutritional start' that their parents had, and are falling apart faster - chronic problems are rife. The medication levels that I see are staggering, the drug interactions by themselves hideous and 'intervention' is happening earlier and earlier. These people are sprinting now to try and keep up, not just running. As them why and they're not really sure. Ever more, ever quicker, ever faster and of course on a biological level, there is only so long one can hammer one's adrenals before 'burn out' occurs. But that happens to someone else doesn't it? Since the endocrine system works on a 'one out, all out' basis, the thyroid is rarely far behind and this hampers recovery because the 'fire in the hearth' is burning very low as the thyroid slows down.
When the body loses energy, it is not difficult to see that the repair functions start to fail. Conversely, what I see when the energy is raised is that the body starts to heal what it needs to heal and all manner of problems frankly just 'go away'.
My point here, yes, there is one (!) is that low functioning adrenals or thyroids also have an effect on brain function and tend to make people run on automatic pilot. They haven't got the energy to respond sincerely, even if they could remember how to. They're in permanent, exhausted, 'fight-or-flight' and that's not a good place for strategic thinking, sincerity in communication or relationships, because their mind's just not there, it's off, planning the next thing to be done or wanting to just switch off and sleep.
There may well be people being replaced on a large scale, I don't know, but a lot who are living, breathing humans are 'counting themselves out' because of the way they run their lives, hammer their bodies etc.. and once we're 'in', it's tough to get 'out' again, at least just looking at the biochemistry. We're the perfect take-over planet from this perspective, too damn knackered to resist.
Yet, even under this nutrient deficit, chemical kosh, (merely one way of mind control if you like) I see more and more people unleashing themselves, saying 'I'm not doing this any more, it's killing me' and their changes inspire others and so it goes on.
I have enjoyed this forum for a few years, thanks to all who have supported me on my journey with their contributions.
Kindest regards.
Sheila.