One noticing I have had--related to depression and "mental illnesses"--is that problem behavior is almost always socially-defined, or defined by someone else besides the person who is supposedly depressed or sick.
Take this list of symptoms of depression from www.prozac.com:
>>
"Lack of interest or pleasure in your usual activities and a lack of motivation. Depression makes it difficult to care about things that used to be important. You may have to push yourself to get things done. Even little things can seem a burden. Many people who have depression say they are bored and sluggish, and even if they have no sleep problems, they are tired all the time. Reduced interest in sex is also common."
<<
...Ummm...Is it possible that a person may "normally" lose interest or pleasure in former activities, or "what used to be important?" This symptom also could be interpreted to suggest that it is abnormal to have a loss of interest in "things" period. Is it always abnormal not to care about "things?"
>>
Feelings of guilt, worthlessness, and insecurity. People with depression often feel negatively about themselves, the world around them, and the future. They may feel guilty about things in the past. Many people with depression feel that they are worthless or that their depression is a punishment for something they have done or left undone. Depression can lead to feelings of insecurity and the need to be dependent on others. It can also lead to poor grooming and personal hygiene.
<<
...What's interesting here is the statement about grooming and personal hygiene? It doesn't give a standard for what poor grooming is. Some would define hippies or Aborigines as having poor hygiene because they don't shave their legs or wash their hair seven times per week. I understand the spirit of the statement, but isn't it entirely subjective? It also might lead a person with low awareness to conclude that because they aren't as well-groomed as they could be that they must be depressed. And, hygiene, again is pretty much socially defined.
>>
Difficulty concentrating and thinking clearly. Depression makes it hard to think clearly, and decisions about even small things may be difficult to make. Often, people who have depression cannot concentrate easily - so work and daily routines become less efficient, and feelings of failure and disgust may appear.
<<
This is a whopper. This symptom would have one believe that difficulty concentrating and thinking clearly is depression! It also defines low concentration SOCIALLY--"so work [becomes] less efficient." So, performing poorly at work may be a sympton of depression? Furthermore, I find difficulty concentrating to be intrinsic to the growth process. If one doesn't encounter difficulty concentrating every once in a while then they're probably not challenging themselves mentally to grow...
>>
Fatigue or lack of energy.
<<
Fatigue and lack of energy may be a result of working sixty hours per week, eating nutritionally bankrupt food, ignoring one's spirit, and, heck, being overexposed to certain EM fields. The fact that the Prozac site doesn't qualify this statement, saying that "fatigue or lack of energy" could be caused by something else is irresponsible.
A person may decide to ask for Prozac solely based on this symptom. And, of course, a person may only be fatigued or of low energy COMPARED TO OTHERS. There are individuals who are thriving in the work/play/sleep/eat schedule of this society, and individuals who are dying in it.
>>
Thoughts of suicide. Many depressed people think about death. Thoughts and actions related to death may occur as part of a wish to end pain, suffering, and confusion.
<<
This I find most interesting of all, because the site is offering Prozac as a response to this symptom (presumably). So, the makers and advertisers of Prozac are, in effect, saying that thoughts of suicide are the result of a chemical imbalance and may be wiped away with the addition of their chemical. But I suppose that's not exactly fair since they do recommend therapy and the drug together. I'm only
suggesting that the website itself, and participation in the therapy, seems to ask for a certain materialist belief-system from the outset.
This "symptom" being listed also suggests that it is abnormal to think about death. And, by emphasizing "thoughts of suicide" instead of the feelings of "pain, suffering and confusion" the writer already has shifted attention to effects and not causes.
I, too, have encountered the "zombification" that can happen with friends of mine on prescription drugs.
I'll close with this...The site also advises the reader of the webpage to remember:
"Depression is not something you've brought on yourself, and it doesn't reveal a personal weakness or an inability to cope."
Translation:
(1) You are not responsible for your depression, something or somebody else is. (A posture of blame and powerlessness is encouraged from the beginning).
And (2) Stop trying to cope with it--do anything about it yourself--because depression isn't a problem, it's normal.
...
I guess I can applaud the compassion of the writer by writing that depression doesn't mean that one is weak. And even the "normalizing" of depression is laudable--life has seasons. But THE WAY that they normalize depression, I believe, invites a victim consciousness (again: "I can't do anything about it...")
You can't change a tiger's stripes,
but you can avoid its teeth.